Analysis of the Relationship between the National Interests of the Islamic Republic of Iran and the International System and its Feedback on the Orientation of Foreign Policy

Document Type : Original Article

Authors

1 Associate Professor of International Relations, Department of Political Science, Faculty of Law and Political Science, University of Mazandaran, Babolsar, Iran. (Corresponding Author)

2 PhD Student in Political Science, Department of Political Science, Faculty of Law and Political Science, University of Mazandaran, Babolsar, Iran.

3 Associate Professor of Political Science, Department of Political Science, Faculty of Law and Political Science, University of Mazandaran, Babolsar, Iran.

Abstract
Introduction: National interests, as common and long-term goals of the state and nation pursued in the global arena, shape the orientation of foreign policy of countries; the most important of these goals are the preservation of independence, territorial integrity, national sovereignty, social system, security and welfare of citizens. With the 1979 revolution, political elites presented a new definition of national interests in the form of the ideology of the system, which was incompatible with the norms and requirements of the structure of the international system. Accordingly, it is necessary to conduct the following research so that through such a way, the country's diplomatic apparatus can reconstruct itself theoretically to secure national interests. The authors intend to conduct a realistic reinterpretation of the country's national interests by taking a look at the idealistic and ideological definitions of the Islamic Republic of Iran of national interests on the one hand and paying attention to the objective developments that have brought today's world to the "post-ideological" era on the other. In this regard, the main question of the research is: Given the incompatibility of national interests with the structure of the international system, what strategy in the field of foreign policy can best serve the national interests of the Islamic Republic of Iran? The main hypothesis is based on the fact that in the political structure of the Islamic Republic of Iran, national interests consist of two parts: subjective and objective. Creating a balance and equilibrium between these two parts provides the basis for securing and continuing national interests.
Research Method: The research ahead is a theoretical/applied research that uses the theoretical foundations of pragmatism to explain the subject of the research, and the research method is qualitative content analysis. In this research, three categories of variables play a role; the independent variable is the realist structure of the international system. The dependent variable is the foreign policy strategy of the Islamic Republic of Iran. The intervening variable itself is divided into two parts: A - The internal intervening variable, which is the continuation of the ideological strategy in the structure of the government of the Islamic Republic of Iran. B - The external intervening variable will be the action and reaction between the forces interested in the discourse of the Islamic Revolution and the international system. Therefore, the national interests of the Islamic Republic of Iran are located in the center of a square whose sides are domestic policy, foreign policy, ideology, and the international system.
Discussion and Conclusion: The four main characteristics that are effective in formulating the national interests of the Islamic Republic of Iran and give direction to its foreign policy are: "independence and negation of domination", "Islamic globalization", "Islamic internationalism", "anti-hegemonicism" (Mahmoudikia and Dehshiri, 29:2010-22). In total, by considering two factors, a general understanding of the nature of the national interests of the Islamic Republic of Iran can be achieved, including: first; the Constitution of the Islamic Republic of Iran and second; the perspective of its leaders.
A - The Constitution of the Islamic Republic of Iran:
The highest goals and ideals that constitute the main infrastructure of the Islamic Republic of Iran's government's grand planning in the field of foreign policy are stated in Article 3 of the Constitution as follows:
- Complete rejection of colonialism and prevention of foreign influence;
- Elimination of any tyranny, autocracy and monopolization;
- Development and consolidation of Islamic brotherhood and general cooperation among all people;
and most importantly, "Regulating the country's foreign policy based on the standards of Islam, fraternal commitment to all Muslims and unwavering support for the oppressed of the world."
B - The leaders' perspective:
B 1- Imam Khomeini: Imam Khomeini does not recognize the definitions of the term "national interests" in the literature of politics and international relations and offers a new explanation of national interests. The main axis of Imam Khomeini's political strategy, on which the definition of national interests is also based, is political Islam. Accordingly, he considers securing the national interests of the Islamic Republic of Iran dependent on the interests of the Islamic Ummah.
B 2 - Ayatollah Khamenei: Regarding national interests, Ayatollah Khamenei's view is not much different from that of Imam Khomeini. In general, his view on national interests can be explained around several elements:
- National interests as a religious identity
- National interests as a revolutionary identity
- Compatibility of the national interests of the Islamic Republic of Iran with the national interests of other Muslims
- Synchronization of ideology and national interests in the diplomacy of the Islamic Republic of Iran
The national interests of the Islamic Republic of Iran are in conflict in two areas:
A - Incompatibility of idealism with realism
B - Incompatibility of ideology and rationality
The incompatibility of the national interests of the Islamic Republic with the international system has faced the country with serious challenges at three levels: national, regional and global.
Conclusion: The incompatibility of national interests in the dictionary of the Islamic Republic of Iran with national interests in the global system is natural because this incompatibility is rooted in the deep difference between the principles governing the international system and the Islamic principles and ideals and revolutionary values ​​governing the foreign policy of the Islamic Republic of Iran. What solution can be adopted in such circumstances? Obviously, a solution must be adopted that, while maintaining ideological ideals, also resolves the incompatibility with the international system. The proposed solution is the application of a result-oriented pragmatism approach. Based on this approach, prior beliefs about national interests and foreign policy must be reviewed or de-prioritized so that posterior beliefs that are the result of practical interactions between the foreign policy of the Islamic Republic of Iran and the international system can replace them. The axis of achieving such an understanding is this principle: "What is true is put into practice and what is put into practice is true." In this approach, it is sufficient for the Islamic Republic of Iran to update its reading of the ideal, classify its ideals based on the criterion of "practicality or impracticability" and give priority to practical goals. The Islamic Republic of Iran would do better to make the most of its relative advantage in the field of soft power and its relative advantage in the cultural field, rather than focusing on a military approach that is not a suitable basis for creating a balance of power with regional and global powers.
 

Keywords

Subjects

Ajili, Had; Zahra Sadri (2024). Pathology of the Foreign Policy of the Islamic Republic of Iran in the Caucasus (From the Collapse of the Soviet Union to 2023-2024. The Journal of Fundamental and APPlied Studies of the Islamic World, Issue 21, Vol. 6, No. 3, Serial No. 21, PP. 61-83. [In Persian]
Agha-bakhshi, Ali; Afshari, Minoo (2004). Dictionary of Political Science, Tehran: Chapter Publishing. [In Persian]
Ali-Bakhshi, Ebrahim; Bayat, Mohammad Hasan (2007). Theoretical Foundations of National Interests, Tehran: Aja Publishing House. [In Persian]
 Ayatollah Khamenei, Ali (2012). Ayatollah Khamenei's Statements at the Meeting of the Participants in the World Summit on Women and Islamic Awakening, available at: https://farsi.khamenei.ir/speech-content?id.  [In Persian]
Ayatollah Khamenei, Ali (2011). Ayatollah Khamenei's Statements in the Sermons of Friday Prayers in Tehran. available at: https://farsi.khamenei.ir/speech-content?id=10955. [In Persian]
Ayatollah Khamenei, Ali (2017). Ayatollah Khamenei's Statements in the Meeting with Regime Officials. https://farsi.khamenei.ir/newspart-index?tid=1651#67044. [In Persian]
Ayatollah Khamenei, Ali (2018). Ayatollah Khamenei's Statements in the Meeting with Ambassadors and Officials of the Ministry of Foreign Affairs, available at: https://farsi.khamenei.ir/news-content?id=40156. [In Persian]
Ayatollah Khamenei, Ali (2009). Ayatollah Khamenei's Statements in a Meeting with Elected Officials of Kurdistan Province, available at: https://farsi.khamenei.ir/speech-content?id=6820. [In Persian]
Behzadi, Hamid (1999). Principles of International Relations and Foreign Policy. Tehran: Dehkhoda Publishing. [In Persian]
Bidar, Esmael; Layali, Mohammad Ali (2021). The Relationship between National Interests and the Unified Islamic Ummah with an Emphasis on the Thought of Imam Khomeini(RA). Scientific Quarterly Journal of Islamic Revolution Studies; 18 (65), PP. 219-238. [In Persian]
Dehghani Firouzabadi, Seyyed Jalal (2014). the Book Summarizing the Foreign Policy of the Islamic Republic of Iran. Pdf Volume. [In Persian]
Eyvazi, Mohammad Rahim (2021). Studies of the Islamic/Iranian Model of Progress; Future Research of the Islamic Revolution, Tehran: Pattern of Progress Publishing. [In Persian]
Ebrahimi, Sharouz (2009). Constructive study of the Role of Ideology in Iran's Foreign Policy and its Connection with Realism and Idealism, Vol 1, Issue 4, Serial No. 4. [In Persian]
Ejitu N. Ota; Chinyere S. Ecoma (2022). Power and National Interest in International Relations, European Journal of Humanities and Social Sciences , PP. 23- 30.
Gharayagh Zandi, Davood (2008). Principles and Foundations of Foreign Policy of the Islamic Republic of Iran: A Survey on the Texts. Strategic Studies Quarterly, 11(40), PP. 277-313. [In Persian]
Khatami, Mahmoud (2007). Considerations on Modernity and Postmodernism; Contemporary Intellectual/Philosophical APProaches in the West, Vol. 4, by the Efforts of the Western Studies Department of the Research Institute of Humanities and Cultural Studies, Tehran: Publications of the Research Institute of Humanities and Cultural Studies. [In Persian]
Khanei, Mohammad Hassan; Mohammadi-sirat, Hosein (2017). The Impact of Ideology on National Interests and National Security in Foreign Policy of the Islamic Republic of Iran; Emphasizing on Imam Khomeini's Ideas (ra). Quarterly Journal of Political Research in Islamic World, 6(4) PP. 91-121. [In Persian]
Khanei, Mohammad Hassan; Mohammadi-sirat, Hosein (2018). The Practical Relationship between National Interest and Islamic Ideology in Foreign Policy of the Islamic Republic of Iran. Journal of Political Sociology of Islamic World, 6(12), PP. 45-72.
Mohammadi Sirat, Hossein (2019), Foreign Policy of the Islamic Republic of Iran; National Interests and Islamic Principles, Tehran: Imam Sadegh University Press. [In Persian]
Mahmoodikia, Mohammad; Dehshiri, Mohammad Reza (2020). The Ratio of Pragmatism to Ideology in Iran's Foreign Policy; Strategic or Tactical APProach? Political Strategic Studies, 9(32), PP. 9-34. [In Persian]
Mahmoudikia, Mohammad (2023). National Interests and Resistance Strategy in I.R.Irans foreign policy; Contrasting or Synergistic?. Journal of Political Knowledge, 19(1), 239-256. doi:10.30497/pkn.2022.240444.2803 [In Persian]
Mousavi, Seyyed Fazlollah; Sarghani, Mohsen; Ramin Nia, Mozhgan; Hossein Zadeh, Hassan (2017). Security and National Interests of the Islamic Republic of Iran in the Light of the United Nations Charter with Emphasizing on the Foundations and Goals of the Islamic Revolution. Islamic Revolution Research, 6(1), PP. 197-215. [In Persian]
Metea, Ileana-Gentilia (2020). National Interest, Terminology and Directions of APProach, International Conference Knowledge-based Organization Vol. XXVI, No. 2020 1, PP. 75- 79.
Naqibzadeh, Ahmad (2009). Theoretical and Practical Challenges in the Foreign Policy of the Islamic Republic of Iran, Foreign Relations Quarterly, Vol 1, Issue 2, Serial No. 2 .PP. 33-55. [In Persian]
Sahifeh-ye Imam Khomeini (2008). Available at: http://en.imam-khomeini.ir/en/c5_3240/Book/English/SAHIFEH-YE-IMAM- Volume 20.
Sahifeh-ye Imam Khomeini (2008). Available at: http://en.imam-khomeini.ir/en/c5_3240/Book/English/SAHIFEH-YE-IMAM- Volume 15.
Sahifeh-ye Imam Khomeini (2008). Available at: http://en.imam-khomeini.ir/en/c5_3240/Book/English/SAHIFEH-YE-IMAM- Volume 10.
Sahifeh-ye Imam Khomeini (2008). Available at: http://en.imam-khomeini.ir/en/c5_3240/Book/English/SAHIFEH-YE-IMAM- Volume 3.
Sabzian Mosiabadi, Alireza; Bahman, Shuaib (2010). Pragmatism and Politics: A Study and Critical Review of Pragmatism in the Sphere of Government and Politics Subject Areas, International and political Research Quarterly, Issue 5, Vol. 2, PP. 89- 123. [In Persian]
Seifi, Abdolmajid; Mohammadnia, Mahdi (2024). The Status of Wedge Strategy in the Foreign Policy of the Islamic Republic of Iran (Case Study: Persian Gulf Cooperation Council). The Journal of Fundamental and APPlied Studies of the Islamic World, Issue 21, Vol.6 , No.3, Serial No. 21, PP. 165-189. [In Persian]
Republic of Iran (Case Study: Persian Gulf Cooperation Council)
Simbar, Reza; Rahmdel, Reza; Fallah, Mahsa (2006). Iran Nuclear Security Dilemma from the Perspective of Neo-Realism Subject Areas: International Relations Studies, Issue 36, Vol. 9, PP. 87- 106. [ In Persian]
Shariatmadari, Ali (2004). Philosophy, Tehran: Publications of the Department of Islamic Literature. [In Persian]
Salehi, Javad; Razavi, Seyyed Kazem (2017). National interests in theoretical perspective Subject Areas: Political and International Researches Quarterly, Issue 30, Vol. 8, PP. 125-149. [In Persian]
The Constitution of the Islamic Republic of Iran, available at: https://www.ekhtebar.ir/wp-. [In Persian]