تحلیل بحران روابط قطر و عربستان سعودی در چارچوب قدرت نرم قطر

نوع مقاله : مقاله پژوهشی

نویسندگان

1 پژوهشگر مقیم در مرکز آیندهپژوهی جهان اسلام

2 موسسه تاریخ و فرهنگ ایران،دانشگاه تبریز

3 دانشجوی دکتری مطالعات منطقه ای دانشگاه جامع امام حسین

چکیده

با قطع روابط عربستان و چند کشور منطقه با قطر در سال 2017، منطقه خلیج‌ فارس وارد یک بحران پیچیده سیاسی شد. تحلیلگران، دلایل متعددی را برای بروز این بحران بیان می‌کنند؛ در این میان به نظر می‌رسد این اقدامات بیش از هر چیز نتیجه موفقیت‌های دوحه در سیاست خارجی خود و مطرح‌شدن این کشور به‌عنوان بازیگر مهم منطقه‌ای در کنار بازیگران سنتی خاورمیانه باشد. در پاسخ به این سوال که بهره-گیری قطر از قدرت نرم در سیاست خارجی، چه تأثیری بر شکل‌گیری بحران خلیج فارس داشته، این مقاله دریافته است که دولت قطر از 2011 به بعد توانسته با بهره‌گیری از قدرت نرم به‌عنوان ابزاری تأثیرگذار، سیاستی مستقل از قدرت‌های سنتی منطقه اتخاذ کند؛ موضوعی که سبب نارضایتی عربستان، به‌عنوان یکی از این قدرت‌ها شد. این پژوهش در تلاش است تا با بهره‌گیری از روش توصیفی- تحلیلی با نگاهی به اختلافات قطر و عربستان و بررسی دقیق نقش قدرت نرم دوحه، به تحلیل ریشه‌ای عوامل شکل‌گیری و تشدید بحران در روابط قطر و عربستان سعودی بپردازد. یافته‌ها و نتایج پژوهش نشان می‌دهد که موفقیت قطر در به‌کارگیری قدرت نرم خود، یکی از مهم‌ترین عوامل اختلاف‌برانگیز دوحه-ریاض بوده است.

کلیدواژه‌ها

موضوعات


عنوان مقاله [English]

Analysis of the crisis in Qatar-Saudi Arabia relations in the framework of Qatar's soft power

نویسندگان [English]

  • Mohammad Reza Mohammadi 1
  • Reza Nasiri Hamed 2
  • Saeed Rabie 3
1 IIWFS
2 Tabriz Uni
3 Emamm Hosein Uni
چکیده [English]

With the severance of ties between Saudi Arabia and several countries in the region with Qatar in 2017, the Persian Gulf region entered a complex political crisis. Analysts cite several reasons for the crisis; In the meantime, these measures seem to be, above all, the result of Doha's success in its foreign policy and its emergence as an important regional player alongside traditional Middle Eastern actor. In response to the question of how Qatar's use of soft power in foreign policy has affected the formation of the Gulf crisis, in this article we found that the Qatar government has been using soft power as an effective tool of politics since 2011. It is independent of the traditional powers of the region.
Qatar is one of the countries that has been able to increase its importance and influence from a small country and a particle to an active level in the region and even effective participation in international coalitions in recent years, especially after 2011, and has played a role beyond its position and capacity, It has been able to play an active role at the regional level while ensuring its security and stability. The extent of events in the geographical area of ​​the region indicates the influence of Qatar's foreign policy. In fact, given the inherent vulnerability of this country, including low population and manpower, small size and small Gulf countries under the protection of Saudi Arabia and its two strengths, namely wealth and media, we can say that this country has been able to achieve many successes. In recent years. In the last decade, Qatar has been able to make good use of its soft power components, such as funding, powerful tools of Al Jazeera television, active public diplomacy and strong ties with world powers, and despite its power constraints, it has emerged as a major regional player.. Of course, this active presence in regional crises and trends has also caused problems for this country, such as the severance of political relations and economic sanctions by several Arab countries in the region in 2017, which is referred to as the Persian Gulf crisis. According to many experts, the crisis in Qatar's relations with these countries is the result of its success in foreign policy and its transformation into an influential actor alongside other traditional actors in the region, including Saudi Arabia and the Foreign policy in which soft power is one of the most important tools. The question is, what tools and capacities does Qatar use to benefit from soft power? And what effect does Qatar's success have in using soft power tools which created a crisis in its relations with other Arab countries in the region? In this research, by descriptive-analytical method and with the assumption that Qatar accurately and calculated use of soft power tools, as one of the main reasons for the success of the country's foreign policy and consequently one of the main differences in Doha's relations with Riyadh and other Arab countries sanctioning Doha, let us analyze the reasons for the formation of these differences. It is important to answer this question in the light of the fact that research on the crisis in Saudi-Qatari relations has so far failed to address the extent to which Qatar enjoys soft power and its impact on the formation and intensification of the crisis.
According to Joseph Nye, soft power has always been an important element of leadership. Leadership is intertwined with power, and leaders must have accurate estimates of the types of power they use. "Power has never been created from barrels of gunpowder," says Nye, a leader who ignores the importance of soft power. For a country like Qatar with low hardware capabilities, because of its small size and population, using soft power tools is the best choice to advance foreign policy. In general, the security forces, the traditional and great powers of the region, which themselves are competing with other great regional and supra-regional powers in order to advance the goals of national foreign policy, do not accept the presence of emerging powers. Qatar's entry into regional games, especially after the Islamic Awakening, and its success in advancing its goals through tools such as active diplomacy, the use of media, alliances with regional and supra-regional opposition poles, and financial support for opposition groups in any case. With the foreign policy of the traditional powers in the region, caused tensions between the country and Saudi Arabia. Of course, what happened in the form of the severance of relations between Saudi Arabia and several Arab countries with Qatar in 2017 was, above all, due to the ideological divide between the Salafis and the Brotherhood between the two countries. The division, which has manifested itself in the form of financial and media support, especially after 2011 in Qatar's support for Hamas in Gaza, Morsi in Egypt, pro-Turkish armed groups in Syria and Libya. Tensions that escalated into a political and economic crisis on the part of Saudi Arabia and several other countries eventually led to the severance of diplomatic relations. Investigating the causes of the crisis in Qatar-Saudi Arabia relations, some of which are referred to as the Persian Gulf earthquake, as well as looking at the conditions that these countries have set for the lifting of sanctions against Qatar, confirms well that Saudi Arabia wants to cut off soft power. Qatar is thereby removing the country from the regional equation as an emerging rival. This is primarily due to Qatar's success in using soft power tools to make it an important player in the tense Middle East region, as well as the importance of soft power as a powerful and effective tool in foreign policy, away from traditional power principles such as military sophistication and Shows large crowds.

کلیدواژه‌ها [English]

  • Soft power
  • Qatar
  • Saudi Arabia
  • Diplomatic Crisis
  • Persian Gulf
  1. Abdulrazaq, Tallha, Qatar’s Iran policy is pragmatic, not idealistic, https://www.trtworld.com/opinion/qatar-s-iran-policy-is-pragmatic-not-idealistic-38841.

2.      Abraham,George (2008). Qatar is a Diplomatic Heavy-Hitter,  www.aljazeera.com/focus/2008/07/ 2008721647355567644.

3.      Abu-Sharkh, Ahmed (2020). Potential impact of COVID-19 on the Qatar economy, May 2020, PP.22.

4.      Al Omran, Ahmed (2017). Gulf media unleashes war of words with Qatar,  https://www.ft.com/content/36f8ceca-76d2-11e7-90c0-90a9d1bc9691.

5.      Al-Zayani, Muhammad (2005). The Al-Jazeera Phenomenon: Basic Perspectives in the New Arab Media, The Model Publishers, Cairo: ISBN 1-5945-1126-8. [In Arabic]

6.      Anzawa, Munehiro (2011). Al Jazeera as a Political Tool Within the Contradictions of Qatar,The American University in Cairo, School of Global Affairs and Public Policy, A Thesis Submitted to the Department of Middle East Studies.

7.      Asadi, Ali Akbar (2011). The Role of Qatar in the Popular Uprisings of the Arab World: Capacities and Constraints, Policy-Making Quarterly, Vol. 2,  No. 4. [In Persian]

8.      Batora, J. (2005). Public Diplomacy in Small and Medium Size States: Norway and Canada, Cllingdeale Discussion Papers in Diplomacy, Vol. 97.

9.      Blanchard, M. Christopher (2010).Qatar:Bachground and U.S Relations, CRS Report for Congress, 5 may.

  1. Borger, Mohammad (2020). US and Taliban sign deal to withdraw American troops from Afghanistan, .

11. Cooper, Andrew; Bessma, Momani (2011). Qatar and Expanded Contours of small stateDiplomacy,The International spevtor, Vol. 46, No.3.

12. De Jone, Maaike (2011). The Place branding of Qatar, Research in Hospitality Management,Vol. l.

13. Dehghani Firoozabadi, Seyed Jalal (2008). A Conceptual Framework for Evaluating the Foreign Policy of the Islamic Republic of Iran, Tehran, Shadan Publications. [In Persian]

  1. Dickinson, Elizabeth (2014). The Case Against Qatar, http://foreignpolicy.com/2014/09/30/the-case-against-qatar.

15. Ekhtiari Amiri, Reza (2011). Roots of Tensions in Saudi-Qatar Relations and the Perspective of the Persian Gulf Cooperation Council, Tehran, Research Center of the Islamic Consultative Assembly. [In Persian]

16. El-Nawawy, Mohammad; Iskander, Adel (2003). Al Jazeera: the Story of the Network that is Rattling Government and Redefining Modern Journalism, Boulder, Westview.

17. Elshenawy, Ahmed Adel (2017). Globalization’s Effect on Qatari Culture, IAFOR Journal of Cultural Studies, Vol. 2, No. 1.

18. Emami, Mahmoud (2010). Influential foreign factors in the Persian Gulf, Tehran, Ministry of Foreign Affairs Publications. [In Persian]

  1. Fandy, Mamoun, (2007). Civil war of words: media and politics in the Arab world, Westport, CT: Praeger Security International.

20. Ghanbarloo, Abdullah (2011). Patterns of Soft Power in the Middle East, Quarterly Journal of Soft Power Studies, Vol. 1, No. 1. [In Persian]

21. Ghareeb, Edmund (2000). New Media and the Information Revolution in the Arab World: An Assessment, Middle East Journal, Vol. 54, No. 3.

22. Hassan Abdo, Hassan (2017). Al-Jazeera: a news channel that has turned into a political player, http://www.emaratalyoum.com/politics/news/2017-08-24-1.1021837. [In Arabic]

23. Hazime, Hanan (2011). from city branding to e-branda in developing countries:An approach to Qatar and Abu Dhabi, African Journal of Business Management, Vol.5, No. 12.

24. Hounshell, Blake (2012). The Qatar buble,  http://www.foreignpolicy.com/artocles/2012/04/23/the_qatar_bubble?=0>(29.

25. Jafari Valadani, Asghar (). Iran and the Persian Gulf :Past and Future Perspectives, Middle East Studies Quarterly,Vol. 3, No. 1. [In Persian]

 

27. Kechichian, Joseph A. (2014). The making of a GCC Crisis,  http://gulfnews.com/news/gulf/Saudi-arabia/the-making-of-a-gcc-crisis-1.1299809.

28. Kessous, Mustapha (2011). Sports as Diplomacy: How small Gulf Countries Use Big Sports to Gain Global Influence,  htpp://nijhoffonline.nl/book?id=nij9789004179400_nij9789004179400_i-309.

29. Khani, Tahereh (2007). Policy Making in Al-Jazeera Network, Radio Magazine, Vol. 6, No. 37. [In Persian]

30. khatib, Lina (2013). Qatar’s foreign policy: The Limits of Pragmatism, International Affairs, No. 89.

31. Leahy, Tom (2020). In Europe, These Are 10 Deals That Did Close in March, https://www.rcanalytics.com/europe-10-deals-march/.

32. Melissen, Jan (2005). The New Public Diplomacy: Soft Power in International Relations, New York, palgrave macmillan.

33. Mir Razavi, Firoozeh (2004). Guide to the region and the countries of the Persian Gulf, Tehran, Abrar Contemporary Publications. [In Persian]

34. Mohammadi, Manouchehr (2008). Sources of Soft Power, Social Capital of the Islamic Republic of Iran, 15th Khordad Magazine, Vol 3, Year 5, Vol 16. [In Persian]

35. Mottaqi, Ibrahim (2012). Proxy Role: A Study of Qatar-US Security Cooperation, Hamshahri and Diplomatic Political-Analytical Monthly, Nos. 64, 59 and 69. [In Persian]

36. Naderi, Qutbuddin (2003). Transfer of US Air Base from Saudi Arabia to Qatar, Opinions and Analyzes, Journal of Political and International Studies, Vol. 17, No. 169.  [In Persian]

37. Nay, Joseph (2010). The soft power of success tools in international politics, translated by Seyed Mohsen Rouhani and Mehdi, Imam Sadegh University Press. [In Persian]

  1. Nuruzzaman, Mohammed (2017). Saudi rift with Qatar exposes growing division in the anti-Iran alliance, http://theconversation.com/saudi-rift-with-qatar-exposes-growing-division-in-the-anti-iran-alliance-78894.

39. Nye, Joseph (2003). Soft Power, translated by Mohammad Hossein Moghadam, Strategy Quarterly, No. 29. [In Persian]

40. Oftrit, Kruber (2001). Al Jazeera: CNN Arab World, translated by Q. Long, Political Translator, No. 44. [In Persian]

41. Piper, Nicola; Uhlin, Anders (2004). Problems of Power and Democracy, Routledge,

42. Qalam Information Exchange website, 12/24/2015, www.qalm.gov.qa. [In Arabic]

43. Qatar General Secretariat for Development Planning Qatar National Development Strategy:2011~2016, Doha: Gulf Publishing and Printing Company.

44. Rajab, Hussam (2015). Qatar tops the list of the richest countries in the world for the year 2015, Global Finance Monthly Magazine. [In Arabic]

45. Roberts, David (2009). Qatar’s search for security, Proceedings of the Plymouth Postgraduate Symposium, 245-246.

46. Rockower, Paul (2012). Recipes for Gastro diplomacy, Place Branding and Public Diplomacy. OAC Print.

47. Safavi, Seyed Hamzeh (2015). Collection of Islamic Countries, Qatar, Tehran, The Institute for Islamic World Futures Studies. [In Persian]

48. Sharp, Jeremy M. (2003). The Al Jazeera News Network: Opportunity or Challenge for U.S.Foreign Policy in the Middle East?,CRS Report for Congress,23 July,p.7.

  1. Statista (2019). Natural gas production - Qatar 1998-2019, https://www.statista.com/statistics/265336/natural-gas-production-in-qatar/.

50. Ulrichsen, Coates Kristian (2012). Small states with a big role: Qatar and the United Arab Emirates in the wake of the Arab spring, HH Sheikh Nasser al-Mohammad al- Sabah Publication series, Durham University, No.3.

  1. US-Qatar Business Council (2019). Energy and Resources in Qatar, https://www.usqbc.org/energy-and-resources-in-qatar.

52. Waezi, Mahmoud (2010). The Role of the Great Powers in the Persian Gulf Region and the Challenges of American Hegemony, International Quarterly Journal of Foreign Relations, Vol. 2, No. 6. [In Persian]

  1. World Bank (2020). Qatar's Economic Update-April 2020, https://www.worldbank.org/en/country/gcc/publication/qatar-economic-update-april-2020.
  2. World Meters (2020). Qatar Natural Gas, https://www.worldometers.info/gas/qatar-natural-gas/.

55. Yazdfam, Mahmoud (2011). Developments in the Arab World: Formulating Power and Identity in the Middle East, Strategic Studies, Vol. 14, No 2. [In Persian]

56. Zayani, Mohamed (2010). The Al Jazeera Phenomenon Critical Perspectives on New Arab Media, London, N6 5AA, UK.