معادلۀ منزلت‌طلبی روسی در بحران‌های ژئوپلیتیکی جهان اسلام، مطالعۀ موردی سوریه و یمن

نوع مقاله : مقاله پژوهشی

نویسنده

استادیار گروه روابط بین الملل، دانشکده امنیت ملی، دانشگاه و پژوهشگاه عالی دفاع ملی، تهران، ایران

چکیده

منزلت‌طلبی به‌مثابۀ یک چارچوب تحلیلی در سیاست خارجی نشان می‌دهد که چگونه روسیه در بحران‌های ژئوپلیتیکی، نقش‌های متفاوتی ایفا می‌کند. منزلت‌طلبی روسی، متأثر از بینش ژئوپلیتیک و هویت تاریخی روسیه، سبب تبدیل‌شدن این کشور به یک کنشگر تأثیرگذار در بحران‌های ژئوپلیتیکی جهان اسلام بوده است. مسئلۀ اصلی این پژوهش ارتباط میان منزلت‌طلبی در سیاست خارجی روسیه و عملکرد متفاوت این کشور در بحران‌های ژئوپلیتیکی خاورمیانه است. این پرسش مطرح می‌شود که چه معادله‌ای میان منزلت‌طلبی روسی و عملکرد متفاوت مسکو در دو بحران ژئوپلیتیکی سوریه و یمن وجود داشته است؟ در پاسخ این فرضیه می‌آید که بحران‌های ژئوپلیتیکی خاورمیانه به اندازه‌ای که بر دو مؤلفۀ هویت تاریخی و گسترۀ ژئوپلیتیک و ژئواکونومیک روسیه تأثیر می‌گذارند، رفتار منزلت‌طلبانۀ روسیه را تحت تأثیر قرار می‌دهد. یافته‌ها نشان می‌دهد بحران یمن برخلاف سوریه، ظرفیت‌های ژئوپلیتیکی لازم برای ایفای نقش یک قدرت جهانی از سوی روسیه را نداشته است. در مقابل، بحران سوریه به‌دلیل تداخل متغیرهای ژئوپلیتیکی منطقه‌ای و جهانی و همچنین ارتباط تاریخی آن با هویت روسی و امپراتوری شوروی، فرصت مناسبی برای پیشبرد راهبرد منزلت‌طلبی روسیه بود. معادلۀ منزلت‌طلبی روسی و بحران‌های ژئوپلیتیک در خاورمیانه سبب شده است تا مسکو تمایلی برای ورود به الگوهای دوستی و دشمنی در منطقۀ خاورمیانه نداشته باشد. به بیان دیگر در معادلۀ روسی، تقویت یا تضعیف محور مقاومت یا سازش اصالت ندارد.

کلیدواژه‌ها

موضوعات


عنوان مقاله [English]

The Equation of Russian Status-seeking in the Geopolitical Crises of the Islamic world; Study of Syria and Yemen

نویسنده [English]

  • Davood Karimipour
Assistant Professor, Department of International Relations, Faculty of National Security, Supreme National Defense, Tehran, Iran
چکیده [English]

The status-seeking of actors in the international arena is not necessarily based on a specific driver. What variables actors in foreign policy are most influenced by will play a decisive role in orienting it towards prestige is a disputed issue in international politics. Some other analysts point out that the status-seeking of world powers in the international system should be divided into large and small countries. In fact, according to researchers, the status-seeking of large powers is quite different from that of small powers. Russia as a big power in the Middle East could be regarded as status-seeking power in today's international system. Although the role of personal concerns can be traced to the direction of the country's foreign policy, other factors still dominate the country's foreign policy. Russia's foreign policy drives seem to be significantly similar to its domestic policy drives. Consolidating Russia's economy to maintain domestic economic growth, gain and maintain international prestige and prestige to define and pursue future interests, and maintain its security are among the most important drivers of its foreign policy. Russia's foreign policy is a relatively secure government foreign policy with serious security concerns, and it is also influenced by government foreign policy, which often uses the military option to achieve its goals, rather than relying on soft options. Russian foreign policy scholars place particular emphasis on the extension of Russia's domestic foreign policy. In other words, the role of domestic variables in the foreign policy of the Russian Federation is so significant and influential that without considering and examining these internal elements, a proper understanding of the foreign policy of this country cannot be done. According to some experts, the foreign policy of the Russian Federation does not reflect the ordinary interests of a state, but its most important feature is the influence of currents, groups, and competition between networks of power within the country. In addition, the role of cultural ideas in seeking prestige in Russian foreign policy cannot be ignored. The component of national culture has a significant role in shaping Russia's foreign policy so that its traces can be seen in all foreign policy actions of this country. By studying the strategic culture of this country, one can better see the relationship between the goals, motives, and international actions of this great actor and evaluate its behavioral patterns in managing international crises such as Ukraine and Syria. Some Domestic Foreign Policy Observers What was most evident in Putin's foreign policy during this period was the dominance of an identity-oriented approach in Russian foreign policy. From Putin's point of view, power and influence are strongly dependent on the question of national identity and the extent to which the citizens of a country consider themselves a nation and relate to their history, values, and traditions. Therefore, during this period, he made great efforts to restore Soviet power in the international arena; In other words, the focal point of Putin's foreign policy behavior during this period was based on the strengthening of national identity and nationalist ideas.
In this sense, for the Russians, the concept of great power is psychological and emotional. The Russians believe that Russia has the right to be considered a great power, given its vast geography, vast resources, and history. Russia has always been a leader in history. The leader of international communism, the conductor of European concerts in the nineteenth century, and one of the two world superpowers in the twentieth century has always made Russia an identity of great power in the eyes of its people and politicians. It must be acknowledged, however, that Russia's ambition has relied heavily on Putin's particular foreign policy personality and approach.
Status seeking as an analytical framework in foreign policy shows how Russia plays different roles in geopolitical crises. Influenced by Russia's geopolitical vision and historical identity, Russia's status-seeking has made it an influential actor in the Middle East's geopolitical crises. In this regard, the main issue of research is to understand the relationship between status-seeking in Russian foreign policy and its different performance in the Middle East geopolitical crises. The main question of this article is what the equation between Russian status-seeking is and Moscow's different performance in There have been two geopolitical crises in Syria and Yemen. In answer to this question, the research hypothesis is that the geopolitical crises in the Middle East affect Russia's status quo behavior to the extent that they affect both the components of Russia's historical identity and its geopolitical and geo-economic scope. The findings show that the Yemeni crisis, unlike Syria, lacked the necessary geopolitical potential for Russia to play the role of world power. In the face of the Syrian crisis, due to the interplay of regional and global geopolitical variables, as well as its historical connection to Russian identity and the Soviet empire, it was a good opportunity to advance Russia's strategy of prestige. The equation of Russian status-seeking and geopolitical crises in the Middle East has made Moscow reluctant to enter into patterns of friendship-hostility in the Middle East. In other words, in the Russian equation, strengthening or weakening the axis of resistance or compromise is not the main issue.

کلیدواژه‌ها [English]

  • Russia
  • Status seeking
  • Geopolitical crisis
  • Yemen
  • Syria
Adami,Ali, Keshavarze Moghdam, Elham (2015), The Security Complex of Axis of Resistance in Foreign Policies of Islamic Republic of Iran, Political Studies of Islamic World, Volume 4, Issue 2 - Serial Number 2 [in Persian]
Afzali,R. Dastjerdi,H.K. Dashti M.H (2016)The Study and Analysis of Geopolitical Outcomes of Syrian Crisis on National Security of the Islamic Republic of Iran, Geography, Volume:14 Issue: 50[in Persian]
Ahmadi, Seyed Abas, Ranjbari Kamal and Sharifi, Abdollah(2020), The role of trans-Regional powers in the Geopolitical crises of the Islamic world, Journal of Fundamental and Applied Studies of the Islamic World, Volume:2 Issue: 3[in Persian]
Alidadi, Shahrbano (2012),Iran’s Revolution and Geo-Culture of Resistance in International Politics (1979-2011),Political Quartely, Volume:41 Issue: 4[in Persian]
 
Amiri,Sourosh, Kiani, Javad (2019),Shahid Soliemani’s Discourse in Diploamcy and International Relations Defah Moqadas Quaterly, Vol.5, No 2[in Persian]
Ashrafi, Akbar, Babazadeh Judi, Amirsaeid(2016), Russia and America's Foreign Policy toward the Syrian Crisis, Studies of International Relations Journal, Volume:8 Issue: 32[in Persian]
Athary,Seyed Asadollah, Bahman, Shuaib (2012), Russia and the New Middle East; Strategies and Challenges, Studies of International Relations Journal, Volume:4 Issue: 17[in Persian]
Baev, Pavel (2015), Russia as Opportunist or Spoiler in the Middle East? Italian Journal of International Affairs, Volume 50, Issue 2
 
Borshchevskaya, Anna(2016), Russia in the Middle East Motives, Consequences, Prospects, The Washington Institute, Policy Focus 142
 
Bozorgmehri,Majid, Najafi. Shahla(2019) Analysis of China-Russia strategy in the Yemeni crisis; Alignment with Saudi Arabia or Iran, Quarterly Foreign Relations, Volume:11 Issue: 42[in Persian]
 
Didier, Brice (2017), the Syrian Conflict and Russia’s Search for Regional Hegemony in a Contested Middle East: Implications for the Euro-Atlantic Community, Department of EU International Relations and Diplomacy Studies
 
Ebrahimikiapei Hadi(2019), Historical background of strategic culture of "egalitarianism" in foreign policy of Shah Abbas Safavi, Journal of Political Research in Islamic World, Volume:9 Issue: 2 [in Persian]
 
Gotz, Elis(2020), Status Matters in World Politics, International Studies Review
 
Hajiloo,Mohammad hossien,VandshokriHossein, Rouhallah, Zahra, Qasemaqdami(2018),Review of Reasons in Russian acting in Syrian crisis, New attitudes in Human Geography, Vol 11, No 1 [in Persian]
 
 
 Olazábal, txaso Domínguez de, Hamad, Leyla(2019), Russia’s Multidimensional Approach to the Yemen War, https://www.ispionline.it/en/pubblicazione/russias-multidimensional-approach-yemen-war-24697
 
Issaev, Leonid, Korotayev, Andrey (2020), Russia’s Policy towards the Middle East: The Case of Yemen, The International Spectator
 
Jan Parvar, Mohsen Saleh Abadi, Reyhaneh, Bahrami, Jaf Sajed (2021)Analysis and explanation of the geopolitical crises of the Islamic world, Journal of Fundamental and Applied Studies of the Islamic World, Volume:2 Issue: 6
 
Jones, Seth G.(2020), Moscow's War in Syria, CSIS Transnational Threats Project
 
Karamzadeh, Siamak, Alizadeh, Masoud (2019),The Syrian Crisis and the Principle of Non-Intervention in Civil War ,Public Law Studies Quarterly, Volume:50 Issue: 1[in Persian]
 
Koshki, Mohammad Sadegh, Taheri Bezi, Ebrahim(2015) Presence of Russia in the Middle East Under Putin(The revival of Russian influence in the former communist countries),  Central Eurasia Studies quarterly, Volume 8, Issue: 1[in Persian]
 
Kouzehgar Kaleji, Vali (2017),The Russian Federation's Discursive Transformation in Central Asia: From Euro-Atlanticism to a Normalized Modern Great Power (1991-2016), Journal of Central Asia and The Caucasus Studies, No. 97 [in Persian]
 
Larson, Deborah Welch, Shevchenko, Alexei(2010), Prestige Matters: Chinese and Russian Status Concerns and U.S. Foreign Policy, Belfer Center for Science and International Affairs
 
Masoudi,Heydarali(2013),Russian Aims and Motivations to active Presence in Syrian Crisis, Research Center of Iran Parliament ,No 13287[in Persian]
 
Mirzaee, Fatemeh, Heydarpour,Mashallah, Mohammad, Torabi(2015),Syrian crisis, Iran and Balance of Regional and Global, Research on Sciences and Technology, Berlin, Germany[in Persian]
 
Moradinia,Sajad, Pishgahifard, Zahra, Yazdanpanah, Kumars, Zarhi, Bahdor(2019),Impact of geopolits of Russia-US relatons on Their Competitions in the Southwest of Asia, New attitudes in Human Geography, Vol 11, No 1[in Persian]
 
 
Nitoiu, Cristian(2016), Aspirations to Great Power Status: Russia’s Path to Assertiveness in the International Arena under Putin, Political Studies Review
 
 
Paci,Simone, Sambanis,Nicholas and William C. Wohlforth(2020), Status-Seeking and Nation-Building: The “Piedmont Principle” Revisited, Journal of Interdisciplinary History, LI:I
 
Rabiei, Hossin, Heyvadi, MohammadReza, Mottaghi,Afshin, Amirahmadian Bahram(2020) Analyzing of Russia Federation’s Strategy to the contrary of Neighbors at the point of the Strategic Geography View,Human Geography Research Quarterly, Volume:52 Issue: 113[in Persian]
 
 
Ramani, Samuel(2020), The Russian Role in the Yemen Crisis, in Global, Regional, and Local Dynamics in the Yemen Crisis, by S. W. Day, N. Brehony
 
Renshon, Jonathan(2017), Fighting for Status :Hierarchy and conflict in world politics, USA: Princeton University press
 
Rodkiewicz, Witold(2017), Russia’s Middle eastern Policy, Regional ambitions, Global obejctives, center for eastern studies
 
Rumerو Eugene(2019), Russia in the Middle East: Jack of All Trades, Master of None, Carnegie Endowment for International Peace
 
Sadeghi, Seyed Shamsoldin, Lotfi. Kameran(2016), Yemen Crisis and Geopolitical Struggle between the Conservative and Resistance Islamic Axis,World Politics, Volume 5, Issue 1 – No: 1[in Persian]
 
Sadeghi,Seyed Shamseddin, Lotfi, Kamran(2016)Strategic Position of Syria in the Military - Security Equations of Russia ,Journal of Central Asia and The Caucasus Studies, No. 93 [in Persian]
 
Serebrov, Sergey (2017), Yemen Crisis: Causes, Threats and Resolution Scenarios, Russian International Affairs Council, No. 14
 
Sergunin, Alexander (2016), Explaining Russian Foreign Policy Behavior, Germany: ibidem-Verlag
 
Simbar, Reza Shiravand, Sarem (2016)The Relationship of Geopolitical Genome to Foreign Policy: the Case of Russian Federation and Georgia, Journal of Central Asia and The Caucasus Studies, No. 92 [in Persian]
 
Smith, Hanna(2012), Domestic Influences on Russian Foreign Policy: Status, Interests and Ressentiment, in book Russia and its Near Neighbours, by Maria Raquel Freire and Roger E. Kanet, London: Palgrave Macmillan
 
Stepanova, Ekaterina(2016) Russia in the Middle East: Back to a “Grand Strategy” or Enforcing Multilateralism, politique étrangère
 
 
Takhshid, MohammadReza Shoja, Morteza(2019) , Maintaining of Sphere of Influence: Explaining of Russia's Foreign Policy In Syria Crisis, Central Eurasia Studies, Volume:12 Issue: 25[in Persian]
 
 Vahedpour, Seyed Noureddin Diant, Mohsen, Roshan Cheshm Hamed(2021), Examining Russia's foreign policy strategy in the Middle East in the light of the spread of religious extremism in the 21st century,Quarterly of Geography (Regional Planing), Volume:12, Issue: 1 [in Persian]
 
Wohlforth, William C., Carvalho, Benjamin de , Leira , Halvard , Neumann , Iver B(2017),Moral authority and status in International Relations: Good states and the social dimension of status seeking, Review of International Studies, Vol. 44, part 3, pp. 526–546
 
Zahrani,Mostafa, Shiravand Sarem(2017), Study on the impact of strategic culture on foreign policy of Russian Federation, Central Asia and The Caucasus Journal, Volume 23, Issue 97[in Persian]
 
Zare, Sediqeh, Ahmadi, Hamid(2016) Identication of Shiite and Religious Conflict in the Middle East ,International Relations Research Quarterly, Volume:6 Issue: 1 [in Persian]
 
 
 Мартен, Кимберли(2013), Новая Трактовка Российской Внешней Политикиж; Влияние неформалъныx патронажно-клентельныx Cetей, ПОНАРС Евразия,Аналитическая записка, № 274
 
Филимонов, Олег(2018)Кризис в Йемене: перспективы для российской дипломатии?, https://russiancouncil.ru/analytics-and-comments/analytics/krizis-v-yemene-perspektivy-dlya-rossiyskoy-diplomatii/
 
http://www.iras.ir/fa/doc/note/1966