بررسی علایق و نگرانی‌های ژئوپلیتیکی ترکیه در سوریه

نوع مقاله : مقاله پژوهشی

نویسندگان

1 دانش‌آموختۀ کارشناسی ارشد جغرافیای سیاسی، دانشکده علوم انسانی، دانشگاه تربیت مدرس، تهران، ایران

2 گروه جغرافیای سیاسی، دانشکده علوم انسانی ، دانشگاه تربیت مدرس، تهران، ایران

3 گروه جغرافیای سیاسی، دانشگاه تربیت مدرس، دانشکده علوم انسانی، تهران، ایران

10.22034/FASIW.2022.349834.1180

چکیده

کشورهای جهان با توجه به درک موقعیت خود و منافع ملی که از قبل برای خود تعیین کرده‌اند و با توجه به ارزیابی عملکرد دیگر قدرت‌های منطقه‌ای و فرامنطقه‌ای اقداماتی انجام می‌دهند و نقش سیاسی و بین‌المللی ایفا می‌کنند. سوریه به‌عنوان همسایۀ جنوبی ترکیه از دیر باز جزو مناطق مهم و حیاتی برای این کشور محسوب می‌شده است، موضوعی که اهمیت خود را در پی تحولات سوریه و درگیری‌های داخلی در این کشور به خوبی نشان داد. محور اصلی این مقاله شناخت نگرانی‌های و علایق ژئوپلیتیکی ترکیه در سوریه است. از این‌رو با بهره‌گیری از رویکرد توصیفی‌تحلیلی و تکیه بر منابع کتابخانه‌ای در پی شناسایی و تحلیل نگرانی‌ها و علایق ژئوپلیتیکی ترکیه در سوریه از زمان شروع جنگ و بحران در این کشور در سال‌های 2011 تا 2020 هستیم. به‌دنبال پاسخ این پرسش هستیم که نگرانی‌ها و علایق‌ ژئوپلیتیکی ترکیه در سوریه کدامند؟ یافته‌های کتابخانه‌ای و استنباطی که با استفاده از نرم افزار Spssو آزمونT-Test انجام دادیم نشان می‌دهد که علائق ژئوپلیتیکی ترکیه در سوریه عبارت از علایق سیاسی، ژئوکالچری، هیدروپلیتیکی و هیدروکربنی از جمله افزایش عمق راهبردی، رهبری جهان اسلام در منطقه، استفادۀ راهبردی از رود فرات و منابع نفتی است و نگرانی‌های ژئوپلیتیکی ترکیه در سوریه شامل نگرانی‌های ژئواستراتژیکی، سیاسی، امنیتی خودمختاری کردهای سوریه، نفوذ رقبای منطقه‌ای مانند ایران و وجود نیروهای تروریستی و تکفیری است.

کلیدواژه‌ها


عنوان مقاله [English]

Investigating Turkey's Geopolitical Interests and Concerns in Syria

نویسندگان [English]

  • Zahrasadat mehrabian, 1
  • Syrus Ahmady nohadani 2
  • Mostafa Ghadery Hajat, 3
1 graduated in political geography, tarbiat modares university, Tehran, iran.
2 assistant professor, political geography department, tarbiat modares university, Tehran, iran.
3 assistant professor, political geography department, tarbiat modares university, Tehran, iran.
چکیده [English]

Since the beginning of the crisis in Syria, the turkey had problems with this country over issues such as the political activities of the Kurds in PKK and how to divide the Euphrates water and Iskanderun province together. However, since 2011, turkey's foreign policy has become aggressive to the extent that it has provided logistical support as well as supported the establishment of a no-fly zone and military interventions in Syria, and in the last decade has become an active and influential actor in has become the region. Erdoğan government's uneven policies during this period have shown that Turkey has changed its positions many times to keep its interests in Syria stable. He considered the groups useful in achieving their goals in Syria, but it was not long before the extremist thought of a group like ISIS reached Turkey, which considers this country a tyranny, and Turkey's security environment faced insecurity. Besides these issues and solving these concerns, Turkey can also pursue its geopolitical interests. by showing strength in the field of Syrian conflicts, by trying to introduce itself as the superior power of the region, which is also present in NATO, and increase its strategic depth in the region, it can even reach the leadership of the modern Islamic world with the perspective of Latinism, like in the Ottoman era. On the way to achieving his goals in Syria, he can control the source of the Euphrates River and exert pressure on the Syrian government to force them to fulfill their wishes, and by turning this issue, he can go towards oil resources and oil fields and compensate for his lack of resources. Slow down and enter the field of oil geopolitics.
Methodology
The methodology of this research is descriptive-analytical, which has a fundamental nature. In this research, using library studies and field findings, an attempt has been made to investigate Turkey's geopolitical interests and concerns in Syria. In the library findings section, books, media, theses, articles, and internet resources have been used, and field findings have been obtained through a questionnaire (50 items) received from experts in the field of political geography, geopolitics, political science, and international relations. Whose results have been analyzed using Spss software and T-Test?  
Findings
According to the library and field findings that were obtained through the questionnaire and its analysis by the relevant statistical test, it was determined that the strategic position of Syria and its position in the strategic depth of Turkey are the most important in terms of Turkey's geopolitical interest in Syria and gaining power. The Turkish element and their autonomy, as well as the influence of regional powers such as Iran, create the most important geopolitical concern for Turkey in Syria.
Analysis and conclusion
According to the findings of the research, we come to the conclusion that after the justice and Development Party came to power, the theoretical background of the country's foreign policy was founded by Ahmet Davutoğlu with the name of strategic depth, and he believed that Turkey, due to its unique geographical location, its cultural and historical depth, as a result of the Ottoman Empire, should be the main country that injects the power and glory of the Ottoman period in a new form to Turkey, which has political and ideological alignment tendencies with the west. Even Islam should be introduced in a new form to the leadership of Turkey that is democratized and does not conflict with western politics. In order to achieve these goals, he must create a mental structure in the form of Ottomanism thinking in the countries that were once part of the Ottoman Empire and he wants to expand his influence in them. Creating a savior mindset from Turkey will help significantly in this country's rise to power in the region. This mentality shows that countries like Syria are like a toddler in Turkey's mind that has not yet been able to communicate with political independence and must face political and ideological salvation. Ideological depiction of Turkey through tools such as movies and series indicates that this government has taken steps to create this mentality. If we look at this country's support for the Muslim Brotherhood and the Akhrani regime in Syria, we will find that the desired behavior structure of Turkey was found in these groups, which is the wife of Turkey's interests. And the Kurdish minority in Turkey has been ignored and suppressed by the Turkish authorities for years, to the extent that they feel like second-class citizens, and now these pan-Kurdish and greater Kurdistan claims in Syria can create a unity that is more dangerous for Turkey than for countries that have a Kurdish population and this geopolitical concern can justify aggressive behavior and, of course, from Turkey's point of view, military defensive behavior in Syria. The danger of the Kurds is so great for Turkey that it uses a concern like terrorist-takfiri forces to face the Kurds, and defeat them because this autonomy is dangerous for the future goals of this country.
According to the library and field findings that were obtained through the questionnaire and its analysis by the relevant statistical test, it was determined that the strategic position of Syria and its position in the strategic depth of Turkey are the most important in terms of Turkey's geopolitical interest in Syria and the empowerment of the Kurdish element and their autonomy and Also, the influence of regional powers like Iran creates the most important geopolitical concern for Turkey in Syria. Therefore, according to the research findings, we reach these results:
After the establishment of the Justice and Development Party, Ahmad Davdaglu founded the theoretical framework of this country's foreign policy under the name of strategic depth. He believed that Turkey, due to its unique geographical location, and cultural and historical depth as a result of the Ottoman Empire, should be a major country that injects the power and glory of the Ottoman period in a new form into a Turkey that has political and ideological alignment tendencies with the West. Even Islam should be introduced to Turkish leadership in a new form that is democratized and does not conflict with Western politics. In order to achieve these goals, he must create a mental structure in the form of Ottomanism in the countries that were once part of the Ottoman Empire and he wants to expand his influence in them. Creating a savior mentality from Turkey will help significantly in this country's rise to power in the region. This mentality shows that countries like Syria in Turkey's mind are like a toddler who has not yet been able to communicate with political independence and must face political and ideological salvation. The ideological depiction of Turkey with tools such as films and series shows that this government has taken steps to create this mentality. If we look at this country's support for the Muslim Brotherhood and the Brotherhood order in Syria, we will find that the behavior structure desired by Turkey was found in these groups, which is in line with Turkey's interests.

کلیدواژه‌ها [English]

  • geopolitical interests
  • geopolitical concern
  • Turkey
  • Syria
Abdel, Khaled Jamil and Others (2020), Turkish Military Intervention as one of the tools for Implementing the Turkish Foreign Policy Orientations in northern Syria "Operation Peace Spring, as a model". Faculty of arts and Science, Department of Political Science, Applied Science Private University, Amman, Jordan.
Aboultaif, Eduardo Wassim, (2016), Regional and international factors that prolong the Syria crisis, Aberdeen university research archive, available at: http://aura.abdn.ac.uk/handle/2164/15367.
Ahmadi, hamed. Ghorbani, fahimeh (2014), The impact of the Syrian crisis on iran- turkey relations, foreign relations quarterly, 6th year, issue 3, pp 44-7. [In Persian]
Ahmet k. Han (2011), Turkey energy strategy and middle east: Between a rock and a hard place, published by Turkish studies, volume 12, issue 4. available at: https://doi.org/10.1080.14683849.2011.6225110.
Aijala, Anna-lotta, (2010), How is Isis funded, Tallinn university of technology, school of economics and business administration, department of international relation, chair of the international relations and politics.
Almohamad, Hussein, (2016), Oil in Syria between terrorism and dictatorship social sciences journal, Volume 5, issue 2. available at: https://doi.org.10.3390/socsci 5020020.
Amiri, madineh. Abedi safdarabadi, mona (2014), The role of the Syrian crisis on the separatism of the kurds of turkey and Iraq, the 7th new international virtual conference of iran and the world, octobr. [In presian].
Aziz, l. (2020), The Syria Kurd in the us Foreign Policy: Long-term Strategy or Tactical ploy?, available at: http://cecrilouvain.be/wp-content/uploads/2020/note-danaly-laraaziz-version-final.pdf.
Bulent, aras &, Karakaya Polat, Rabia, (2008), from conflict to cooperation: de securitization of Turkey's relation with Syria and Iran available at: https://sdi.sagepub.com/content/39/5/495.short.
Cemgil, C. Hoffman, C. (2016), The "Rojava Revolution" in Syria Kurdistan: A Model of Development for the Middle east? Institute of Development Studies, 47 (3)27-43.
Cevik. B, senem, (2019), Turkish historical television series: public broadcasting of neo-ottoman illusions, journal of southeast European and black sea studies, volume 19, issue 2.
Ceylan, Enes. Kedikli, Umut (2018), The effect of terrorism on the world and Turkey economy in the context of turism sector, international congress of human and social sciences research.
Cheginizadeh, gholamali .asari, ahmadreza (2017), Takfiri groups and the security of the Islamic republic of iran, social order research quarterly, 9th year, 3issue. [In Persian].
Cheginizadeh, gholamali. Asar tamar, mohammad (2009). Kurdish ethnic movements and turkey's national security, international quarterly of foreign relations, first year, second issue, pp 218-185. [In Persian].
Cheginizadeh, gholamali. mousavinia, seyyed reza. Imeni, farshid (2019). Hydropolitics and water conflicts in the tigris and Euphrates rivers (1950-2018), middle east studies quarterly, 26th year, number 4. [In Persian].
Chubin, Sharam, (2012), Iran and the Arab spring : Ascendancy frustrated Gulf research center, available at: http://carnegieendowment.org/files/Iran-and-Arab-spring-2873.
Gok, Naim, (2019). Reflections of Syria crisis to Turkey (2011-2017), uskudar university journal of social sciences, issue:8, vol,77-114.
Gurcan, Efe Can. (2017), "Political geography of Turkey's intervention in Syria: underlying causes and consequences (2011-2016)". Journal of aggression. conflict and peace research. Available at: https://doi.org/10.1108/JACPR-10-2017-03290.
Firouzabadi dehghani, seyyed jalal. Pooresmaili, najmeh (2018), Turkish foreign policy in the middle east: conservative, revisionist and ideological foundations, foreign relation quarterly. 10th year, number 38, pp 104-75. [In Persian].
Hafeznia, mohammadreza (2016), Principles and concepts of Geopolitics, 5th edition, mashhad: papli publications. [In Persian].
Hafeznia, mohammadreza. Rajabiei, hossein (2013), Persian gulf regional studies, samt publication. [In Persian].
International crisis group , (2020), Calibrating the response: Turkey's Isis returnees. Published by international crisis group, available at: http://www.jestor.org/stable/resrep.31268.
Koshki, sadegh. Gudarzi, Maryam (2016), Turkey's strategic role in middle east developments (cace study: Syrian crisis), the third international conference on modern research in management, economic and humanities. [In Persian].
Mearaji, Ebrahim (2020),, Changing the approach in turkey's foreign policy: from the european union to the middle east, political and international research quarterly, number 45, pp 170-31. [In Persian].
Miyanabadi, Hojjat. Amiri, Azam (2019), Intertwining of water, politics and environment in tigirs and Euphrates watershed, geopolitics quarterly, 15th year, 2 issue, PP 86-54. [In Persian].
Mokhtari, hossein. Ghaderi hajat, mostafa (2008), Middle east Hydropolitics in the horizon of 2025: a case study of the tigirs and Euphrates basins, the Jordan rivers, the nile rivers. Geopolitics quarterly, 4th year, issue 1. [In Persian].
Momeni, majidreza. Khademi, atiyeh. Ghorjili, Hamed (2012), The review of turkey's positions and actions in the Syrian crisis based on the decision-making approach, political research quarterly, number 5, pp 178-163. [In Persian].
Naghdi eshratabad, jafar. gharshasbi, reza. Sadeghi, hadi (2019), The structure of the international system and the analysis of the turkey's policy against isis, strategic policy research quarterly, 8th year, number 31. [In Persian].
Niyakuoi, seyyed amir. Sotoudeh, ali asghar (2016), The pattern of conflict between regional and extra-regional actors in the internal conflicts of Syrian and Iraq, strategy quarterly , 25th year, number 80. [In Persian].
Ozdemir, cagtay, (2019), period Turkey's middle east policy: Transformation from construction to realism Justice and development party and rising Turkey, publisher: kadim.
Ruhi dehbaneh, majid (2018). Geopolitical analysis of iran-turkey rivalry effected by the developments in the middle east in 2011, geopolitics quarterly, 14th year, number 1, pp 147-113. [In Persian].
Sabouri, ziauddin. Salehian, tajuddin (2015), Middle east conflict future and changes in the regional power balance of iran and turkey, international relations research quarterly, first volume, number 17, pp 138-105. [In Persian].
Safavi , seyyed hamze. Nabawi, seyyed mehdi (2016), Turkey's behavior towards the light of the doctrine of strategic depth, defense policy magazine, 22th year, number 94. [In Persian].
Saracaglu, Cenk, (2018), The Syrian conflict and the crisis of Islamic nationalism in Turkey, published by Turkey policy quarterly issue 4, volume 16.
Sharifian, jamshid. Abdullah Pour, Hossein. Derafshan, Mojtaba (2016), Turkey's role in the Syrian crisis and its impact on the extranal national security of the Islamic republic of Iran, research security quarterly, 15th year, number 55. [In Persian].
Sharifian, jamshid. Kabiri, abasalt. Tahamanesh, alireza (2012), Interaction and confrontation between iran and turkey in the Syrian crisis, security research journal, volume 11, number 38. [In Persian].
Taghilu, faramarz. Khairi, mostafa (2020), Turkey and the Syrian crisis and the policy of dealing with the emergence of Kurdistan (2011-2020), International policy research journal, year 9, number 1, pp 84-55. [In Persian].
Taspinar, Omer. Tol, Gonal. (2014), "Turkey and the kurd: From predicament to Opportunity" Center of the united State and Europe at brooking, us -Europe Analysis Series namber 54, January 22.
Vela, Justin (2012), '' assad talk of a 'state of war' as rebels attack clashes on outskirts of Damascus a Turkish PM send a warning to the Syrian regim '', 27 june, available at: http://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/middle-east/assad-talk-of-a-state-of-war-as-rebels-attack-7888915.html?origin=internalsearch.
Warner, Jeroen, (2008), Contested hydrohegemony: Hydraulic control and security in Turkey, available at: https://www.water.alternatives.org/index.php/allabs/32-a/2-6/file.
Warner, Jeroen f. zeitoun, mark (2008), International relation theory and water do mix: a response to furlong's troubled waters hydrohegemony and international water relation, political geography 27, pp 810-802.
Yilmaz, Nuh. (2013), "Turkey: goodbye to zero problems with neighbors" In: the Regional Struggle for Syria. European Council on Foreign Relations.
Zaki, yashar. Asadollahi, seyyed soroush (2020), Hydropolitics of the Turkish gap project and its impact on the environmental security of Iraq and Syria, space political analysis quarterly, volume 3, number 1. [In Persian].