موانع و چالش‌های تأثیرگذار در توسعه‌نیافتگی سیاسی عراق پساصدام

نوع مقاله : مقاله پژوهشی

نویسندگان

1 دکتری جامعه‌شناسی سیاسی، دانشکده حقوق و علوم سیاسی، واحد تبریز، دانشگاه آزاد اسلامی، تبریز، ایران

2 استادیار گروه علوم سیاسی، دانشگاه تبریز، تبریز، ایران

10.22034/FASIW.2023.399359.1266

چکیده

موانع و چالش‌های تأثیرگذار بر پیشروی توسعۀ سیاسی کشور مسلمان عراق و مقاومت‌هایی که برای حفظ شرایط گذشته شده است عوامل گوناگونی دارد. در این پژوهش به‌دنبال پاسخ این پرسش هستیم که در فرایند شکل‌گیری توسعۀ سیاسی در عراق بعد از سرنگونی حزب بعث، چه موانع و چالش‌های تأثیرگذاری نقش دارند؟ پاسخ فرضیه این است که دو دسته عوامل داخلی و خارجی، عوامل اصلی عدم توسعۀ سیاسی عراق پسا صدام هستند. عوامل داخلی جنگ و نزاع داخلی بر سر قدرت و تقویت سیاست مبتنی بر هویت‌های قومی و فرقه‌ای، تنش بین اقلیم کردستان و دولت مرکزی و عوامل خارجی، ظهور و حضور سازمان‌های تروریستی همچون داعش، حضور نیروهای ائتلاف به رهبری آمریکا و مداخله در امور سیاسی کشور در دو دهۀ اخیر، فرایند توسعۀ سیاسی پس از فروپاشی حزب بعث را در عراق دچار چالش و گاهی متوقف کرده است. پژوهش حاضر به‌لحاظ روش، توصیفی‌تحلیلی است. در نتیجۀ حرکت در مسیر توسعۀ سیاسی مطلوب می‌تواند یک دگرگونی اساسی در باور سیاسی افراد و نهادهای این کشور باشد که پیش‌فرض‌های آن را تغییر در فرهنگ، اقتصاد و جامعه تشکیل می‌دهند. تغییرات در این حوزه‌ها، عاملی برای تغییر در حوزۀ سیاسی یا تحکیم آن است.
 
 
 
 
 

کلیدواژه‌ها

موضوعات


عنوان مقاله [English]

Obstacles and challenges influencing the political underdevelopment of Iraq after the overthrow of the Baath party

نویسندگان [English]

  • Saeed , Haqparast 1
  • Tohid Valipour Ateeq, 1
  • Reza Nasiri Hamed, 2
1 PhD in Political Sociology, Faculty of Law and Political Sciences, Tabriz Branch, Islamic Azad University, Tabriz, Iran
2 Assistant Professor, Department of Political Science,, Tabriz University, Tabriz, Iran
چکیده [English]

 
Iraq is a country with geopolitical bottleneck, suitable geo-economic position, ethnic and religious diversity, and also under the domination of autocratic rulers throughout history. Ethnic-religious gaps along with cultural-social gaps, especially the activation of historical, ethnic, religious, and tribal faults that became possible after the US military invasion of Iraq in March 2003, created a very favorable environment for militant armed groups in opposition to the central government. The social structure of Iraq, like most countries in West Asia, is a mosaic structure consisting of ethnic groups and different sects. This structure with a diverse and heterogeneous demographic structure was the result of the efforts of extra-regional powers and specifically England to break up the Ottoman Empire after the First World War and form new countries with a mosaic social structure and conflicting identities. The policy of assimilation based on the ideology of pan-Arabism, making the government and the army Arab-Sunni, ignoring other groups and ethnic and religious tendencies, and preventing them from entering the field of political power and cultural development based on ethnic-religious divisions caused the emergence of Kurdish ethnocentrism and Shiism became political This resulted in the formation and strengthening of Shiite and Kurdish groups against the central government and their continuous struggles. Unfortunately, the process of democratization in Iraq showed that the elections and political approaches of the Iraqi people are mostly organized based on identity and ethnicity, and other social institutions are not powerful and comprehensive enough to cover this gap beyond ethnic-sectarian groupings give The authoritarian political structure that has always ruled in these countries has insisted on the rejection of social and political freedoms and the formation of groups, each of which can play a role in the education and growth of the society, and has prevented the process of change towards a multi-vocal society. One of the most important challenges in Iraq after the departure of the occupiers is the competition of ethnic groups and religious groups to take over seats in the parliament and government and important political positions, which has led to a serious competition and conflict between the groups and their supporters, and these disaffected groups, the majority of which are also armed, from time to time launch military operations against each other and cause serious problems for the security of the citizens. Investigating why Iraq fell to the sidelines of the political development process and also the role of influential factors in the lack of political development of this country after the overthrow of the Baath party is the main goal of this research. The effort is to find a scientific answer to this question during this exploration. Among the variables influencing the lack of political development, the internal components of this country, including social, cultural, historical mindsets, political and economic factors, as well as the structure and military and security capabilities of the Iraqi government have a major impact. Since the formation of this country, the social structure of Iraq has been based on numerous ethnic-sectarian divisions, which have appeared at different times despite the efforts of the Baathist regime to define a single Iraqi identity The emergence of politics based on ethnic and sectarian identities as the main way of social and political self-definition and as a result the weakening of social cohesion is one of the main characteristics of the new Iraq, which has a fundamental impact on the security of this country. The rise and spread of terrorism in Iraq has complex dimensions that the main factors involved in it can be divided into two categories: internal factors and external factors On the other hand, the internal factors include the tensions between the Kurdistan Region and the central government of Iraq over the disputed areas, the coming to power of the Shiites and the weakening and isolation of the Sunni Arabs, as well as the tribal fabric of the country of Iraq and On the other hand, external factors include: the emergence and presence of terrorist organizations such as ISIS, the American policy in the fight against terrorism, and the different policies and approaches of the regional powers towards the developments in Iraq, including the main factors in the path of political underdevelopment along with the disorder in Iraq after the overthrow of the regime. They are considered the dictator of BaathIn fact, the hypothesis of this research is that the main factors in the lack of political development in post-Saddam Iraq can be divided into two categories of internal factors: war and internal strife for power and the strengthening of politics based on ethnic and sectarian identities, the tension between the Kurdistan region and the central government and On the other hand, external factors include: the emergence and presence of terrorist organizations such as ISIS, the presence of US-led coalition forces, and interventions in the country's political affairs, etc., in the last two decades, have challenged the process of political development after the collapse of the Baath party in Iraq. Sometimes it has stopped The current research is descriptive-analytical in terms of method As a result, moving in the direction of desirable political development can be a fundamental transformation in the political belief of people and institutions of this country, which presupposes changes in culture, economy, and society. Changes in the mentioned fields become a factor for changes in the political field or its consolidation Providing a suitable solution to get out of the impasse of political underdevelopment and not to deviate from the correct path of progress and all-round development in a country with diversity of ethnic groups, religions and different languages ​​like Iraq, without considering all the effective variables, cannot be useful. The correct path of the political development of Iraqi society requires a fundamental transformation in the political belief of the influential religious institutions and individuals of this country, which are presupposed by changes in culture, economy, and society Instead of turning to Western imitation values, which can increase its vulnerability, the modernist cultural efforts can be focused on the concepts of religious transformation, justice, cooperation, and equality, national unity and harmony, forgiveness, and tolerance, tolerance and Different vision in political and social activities along with attention to the patriotic political elites who everyone accepts should rely on free elections in the way of establishing democracy in order to achieve national unity and integrity  and like them, most of them have religious, ideological and national roots.                   

کلیدواژه‌ها [English]

  • Iraq
  • federalism
  • identity crisis
  • political development
  • terrorism
Ahmadi, Hamid (1997), "Political stability, democracy and civil society in heterogeneous societies: the theory of democracy based on consensus and Lebanese experience", Middle Eastern Journal, No. 12, pp. 123-166. [In Persian]
Akbari, Hossein (2010), "Sovereignty Crisis in Iraq", Tehran: Institute of Andishesazan Noor Studies. [In Persian]
Al-Sayed, Rizvan (2004), "Political Islam in the Struggle of Identity and Modernity", translated by: Majid Moradi, Tehran: Center for the Recognition of Islam and Iran. [In Persian]
Amnesly International. (2014), Absolute Impunity Militaria Rule in Iraq, 4/15/2014.
Arefi, Mohammad Akram (2011), "Obstacles to Political Development in Afghanistan (1370-1298), "Faculty of Law and Political Science, University of Tehran (Doctoral Dissertation) [In Persian]
Azin, Ahmad and Bayati, Parvaneh (2015), "Obstacles to the development of democracy in Iraq, the first international conference of social sciences and sociology, Abadah". [In Persian]
Azize, sardar (2017), The economic system (s) of the Kurdistan regional government, Irag. In Between State and Non-State,. Palgrave Macmillan, New York, 2017    
Bandiera, Luca, Bledi Celiku, and Ashwaq Natiq Maseeh (2018), Iraq Economic    Monitor- From War to Reconstruction and Economic Recovery: With a Special Focous on Energy Subsidy Reform. No. 125406. The World Bank, 2018        
Bashirieh, Hossein (2001), "Obstacles to Political Development in Iran", Tehran: Gam Noo Publications. [In Persian]
Binder, Leonard (1998), "Crises of political development", translation: Gholamreza Khaje Sarvi, Strategic Studies Quarterly, No. 1, pp. 233-244 [In Persian]
Bouillon, M. E. (2012), “Iraq’s state-building enterprise: State fragility, state failure and a new social contract”, International Journal of Contemporary Iraqi Studies, 6(3), 281-297.
Brecher, Michael (2003), "Crisis in World Politics", translated by Heydar Ali Balochi, Tehran: Strategic Studies Institute. [In Persian]
Byman, Daniel (2001). “Iraq after Saddam”. Washington Quarterly, 24, no. 4
Chengu, Garikai (2014), “How The U.S Helped Create A1Qarde and ISIS”, Retrived from Counterpunch.org.
Davis, Eric (2005), History Matters: Past as Prologue in building Democracy in Iraq, Vol. 5, Orbis.
Eisenstadt. M, White. J, Assessing Iraq’s Sunni Arab Insurgency, Published in 2005 in the United States of America by the Washington Institute for Near East Policy.
Forsyth. Murray (1989) Federalism and Nationalism, Leicestar: Leicester University Press, p. 135
Francis, Matthew (2012), “What Cavses Radicalization? Maine Lines of Consensus in Recent Research”, Retrived form radical station research.org.
Hamilton, Alexander (2020), The political economy of economic policy in Iraq. (2020).                                                       
Hamourtziadou, Lily, and Bulent Gokay. The promised spring: death and neoliberalism in Irag. Security Diaioguees 11, no. 1 (2020): 45-60    
- Haq Panah, Jafar (2008), "The Kurds and the Foreign Policy of the Islamic Republic of Iran", Tehran: Abrar Mazazer. [In Persian]
Hetne, Bjorn (2012), Development theory and the three worlds.
Hirishman, A.O. (1984), Pioneers in Development. Oxford: University press.
- Huntington, Samuel (1991), "Political system in societies undergoing transformation", translated by: Mohsen Talasi, Tehran: Nash Alam. [In Persian]
- Huntington, Samuel (2002), "The Third Wave of Democracy", translated by: Ahmad Shahsa, Tehran: Rosenha. [In Persian]
Huntington, Samuel P Dominguez. Jorge. (1975). Political development.
Hussain, Dilly (2016),” ISIS: The Unintended Consequences of the u: Sled wer on Iraq”, Retrieved from foreign policy journal.com.
Kazemi, Hamed, Daneshnia, Farhad, Haji Yousefi, Amir Mohammad (2022), Political Economy of Development in Post-Saddam Iraq: Political Turn or Reproduction of Limited Access Order, Political and International Approaches Quarterly, Volume 14, Number 2 [In Persian]
Khosravi, Alireza (2011), "Increasing Israel's presence in Iraq, expansion and influence strategy", Research Journal of Geographical Research, No. 48, p. 78. [In Persian]
Kincaid. John (2002) Hand Book of Federal Countries, A Project of Federation, Ed. By Ann L. Griffith. New York: McGill Queens University Press, p. 223.
Moradi, Jahanbakhsh (2011), "Examination of federalism in Iraq from the perspective of regional analysis", Political Science Quarterly, No. 17, pp. 35-58. [In Persian]
Mothana, Ibrahim. (2012) “How Drones Help Alqaeda?” Retrieved from New York Times.
Oswaldo de Rivero (2005), "The Myth of Development", translated by: Mahmoud Abdullahzadeh, Tehran: Akhtaran Publishing House. [In Persian]
Pai, Lucin and others (2001), "Crisis and sequences in political development", translated by: Gholamreza Khaje Sarvi, Tehran: Strategic Studies. [In Persian]
Pollack, Kenneth (2015), “U.S Policy toward a Turbulent Middle East”, Washington: Brookings Institution press.
Qavam, Abdul Ali (2011), "Challenges of political development", Tehran: Qoms Publishing. [In Persian]
Report to Congress, October 2005, Measuring Stability and Security in Iraq,”, Department of Defense. (www.defenselink.mil/news/Oct2005/d20051013iraq.pdf )
Sa'i, Ahmed. Moradi, Jahanbakhsh (2011), "Problems of Federalism in Iraq", Journal of Political and International Research, Volume 3, Number 7, pp. 32-31. [In Persian]
Sajjadi, Abdul Qayyum (2013), "Political Sociology of Afghanistan", Qom: Bostan Kitab Publications. [In Persian]
Sardarnia, Khalilullah and Hosseini, Seyed Mehdi (2013), "Social challenges of modern state-building in Afghanistan", World Politics Quarterly, third volume, third issue, pp. 37-63 [In Persian]
Saveh Droudi, Mostafa (2011), "Security Crisis Management", Tehran: Farabi College Publishing. [In Persian]
Seyed Qutb (1997), "Features of Islamic Ideology", translated by: Seyed Mohammad Khamenei, Tehran: Ba'ath, Beta. [In Persian]
Smith, Graham (1995), “Federalism; The Multiethnic Challenge”, London: Longman, pp.203-205.
Tilly, Charles (2006), "From Basih to the Revolution", translated by: Ali Morshidizadeh, Tehran: Imam Khomeini Research Institute (RA). [In Persian]
Transparency. Org (2019), Corruption Perceptions Index report, Transparency International, http:// www. Transparency. Org/en/cpi/2019/results    
Zareian Jeremy, Farajullah (2017), "The Fragile State and Its Roles in the Formation of the Syrian Crisis", Yasouj Faculty of Political Sciences, (dissertation) [In Persian]
Zibakalam, Sadegh (2003), "An Approach to the Causes of the Second Khordad from a Sociological Perspective", Tehran: Shahr Dunya. [In Persian]